Return to Office or Stay Flexible? The Workweek Tug-of-War

Prefer to listen instead of read? No problem! Listen to the blog post by clicking here. 

The workplace tug-of-war is back. Some teams are thriving with flexibility. Some leaders are pushing for a return to the office. Somewhere in between is a version that works for both.  

There's no one-size-fits-all model, but there is a right fit for your company. 

Companies are at a crossroads 

Organizations are either doubling down on in-office attendance or quietly keeping flexible schedules. When it comes down to it, employees make decisions based on how work affects their lives, and leaders need to pay attention.   

Recent data on the nature of return to office (RTO) mandates and flexible work shows how much these choices matter: 

• U.S. professionals spend 1–5% of their annual salary on commuting. 

• Fewer than 2% of employees will commute longer than two hours. 56% won’t go beyond 45 minutes.  

• RTO mandates have triggered a 14% spike in quit rates. 

• 40% of managers are allowing remote work without officially updating company policies.  

Why some teams want to be back in the office 

In-office setups come with certain advantages: structure, easy coordination, quick conversations in the hallway, and direct access to people and resources. For some teams, in-person time shapes their workday. Managers may find it easier to check in, give support, and keep things moving when everyone is in the same place.  

There are teams that thrive in this rhythm. However, it should be a conscious choice, not a fallback.  

What flexible work can offer 

Flexible work changes how time and space are used. People manage their energy with thought and care, and teams develop communication rhythms that fit the way they work. 

Flexible work cultures have been linked to lower absenteeism, stronger retention, and higher job satisfaction. However, leaders have to be deliberate about building culture, setting clear expectations, and maintaining communication. The extra effort pays off for remote teams and the whole organization. 

Leading with intention 

Having a policy is different than having a strategy.  

You can have in-office, flexible, or hybrid policies, but if the day-to-day experience is different, that gap will show in engagement, turnover, and performance. If your team isn’t clear on expectations, it’s a leadership issue. Employees watch how consistent your decisions are and whether their needs are considered. 

If you're navigating this shift, ask a few questions: 

• What does your business require to operate well? 

• How do employees perform in your current setup? 

• Where is communication strong, and where is it breaking down? 

• Are expectations being met without physical oversight? 

The answers will point you in the right direction.  

How to choose what fits your business 

What works for one company may not work for yours. Decide based on your business model, team, and values. 

Choose flexibility if your team delivers results, has solid communication, and your systems support remote work. 

 Here’s what organizations are doing in this space: 

• Setting core collaboration hours while allowing flexible start and end times. 

• Offering remote stipends for home office upgrades, internet costs, or wellness support. 

• Using asynchronous tools like Loom, Slack, or Notion to minimize meetings and support documentation. 

• Building virtual onboarding and mentorship programs to keep new hires connected and aligned. 

Choose RTO if your product or service depends on in-person work, or your operations require physical presence. 

Companies in this category are: 

• Redesigning offices to support collaboration zones and focus areas.  

• Offering on-site perks like wellness rooms or childcare to offset commute trade-offs. 

• Setting regular in-office days to create a flexible schedule.  

• Receiving employee feedback to adapt physical workflows based on team needs. 

Choose hybrid if you want to blend autonomy with in-person collaboration and can support both structures. 

Organizations are making it work by: 

• Giving teams autonomy to set their in-office cadence, often 2–3 days per week. 

• Using workspace booking software to manage space and avoid overcrowding. 

• Assigning team-based office leads to coordinate hybrid logistics and drive culture across locations. 

• Running quarterly surveys to check how well hybrid models are functioning. 

Not sure yet? Try a few options. Listen to your team. Make changes if it’s not working. 

Companies that are still figuring it out are: 

• Trying different work models with rotating teams (e.g., one quarter remote-first, the next hybrid). 

• Running “remote by default” pilots with planned in-person retreats or monthly office days. 

• Forming cross-functional teams to gather employee input and explore new options. 

• Communicating openly about experiments, timelines, and how decisions will be made. 

What to focus on 

Workplace decisions shape how people show up and whether they stick around. People can work in almost any structure; they need clarity, consistency, and a reason to believe the structure is built with intention.  

Set the direction, make it clear, and give your team something worth showing up for.  

Content published by Q4intelligence

Photo by wirestock